Should You Run Your Leadership Team Meeting or Hire a Facilitator?

If your leadership team has to make a decision you’re already arguing for, ask who should run the meeting. You’ll need to make your case, hear what it costs other teams and encourage them to disagree. That’s a lot to do while you’re watching the clock and deciding who speaks next.

I led a workshop where leaders had to weigh a potential opportunity against the time and work it would take from other teams. I asked everyone to write down how they’d weigh it before the discussion. The group talked through the value of the opportunity, the effort it would take and what they’d have less time for if they went ahead.

That’s the kind of conversation where choosing the right person to run the meeting makes it much easier to get to the right decision. Here’s how I’d choose between leading it yourself and hiring an outside facilitator.

Lead it internally when you can make room for disagreement

Run the meeting yourself if you can explain the decision clearly, draw out objections and weigh them fairly. A person on the team who understands the work and has room to hear every side can also chair it. In either case, tell the group up front who makes the decision.

An internal facilitator already knows the history, people and constraints. That saves time getting everyone up to speed. It also makes sense if the decision is one your team needs to learn how to make regularly. Practice with the kind of structure I used in the workshop. Give people a few minutes to write down the tradeoff. Then ask each team what it would have to put off to take on the work.

Consider an outside facilitator when you need to participate

Bring someone in when you need to be fully involved in the discussion and nobody inside the team is in a good position to run it. That’s especially worth considering if the same disagreement keeps coming back, or if the people affected tend to hold their questions until after the meeting.

An outside facilitator adds a fee and needs preparation time to understand your team and the decision. Give them the options you’re weighing, who will have to do the work and where the team disagrees. Their job is to draw out the information you need and help the group work through it. The decision belongs to the person or group you’ve named.

Ask what they’d do when the room disagrees

Before hiring someone, share a real tradeoff and ask how they’d run that part of the meeting. What would they do if the person with the biggest stake speaks first? How would they hear from the teams that have to do the work? What would they write down before people leave?

Start with the next meeting on your calendar. Write the decision in one sentence, name who owns it and decide who can get the facts and objections into the room. If you can do both jobs well, chair it. If you need to be in the discussion, have someone else run the discussion.

Decision guide: chair the meeting yourself if you can make your case and weigh objections fairly; otherwise ask a suitable teammate or outside facilitator. Identify who makes the decision.

Download the facilitator decision guide

Talk with Nathan about a decision your leadership team is facing

Related reading: Your Calendar Is Part of Your Culture

Leave a Reply